Best Pizza Restaurant in New York (2026)

70 businesses found · Ranked by quality, not ads

Find top-rated pizza restaurant businesses in New York. Every business is ranked by Quality Score, our measure of responsiveness, data completeness, and reviews. Not who pays the most.

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.3(463 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.2(3049 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(826 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.5(10208 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(3573 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(291 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.9(141 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.3(1388 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.0(1435 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(441 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.6(2096 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.5(2219 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.7(350 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 3.9(1135 reviews)

Brooklyn, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.2(9539 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.5(430 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(2988 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.2(1142 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.3(8307 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.7(490 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 3.9(1298 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(73 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(707 reviews)

North Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(144 reviews)

East Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.5(498 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(336 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(1586 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.6(8488 reviews)

West Seneca, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 5.0(184 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.7(722 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.9(227 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(394 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.0(781 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(8960 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.5(338 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.7(478 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.3(1318 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(1312 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.7(232 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(1114 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.5(6272 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.3(765 reviews)

Amherst, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.2(2593 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.6(2370 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.6(952 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(125 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(342 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.8(199 reviews)

New York, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.5(24976 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Pizza Restaurant

★ 4.4(1241 reviews)

Don't see your business?

Add your business to Bezal for free and start getting found by AI search engines.

Get Listed on Bezal

Related Categories in New York