Bezal.
Find a ProviderSign In

Best Ice Cream Shop in New York (2026)

76 businesses found · Ranked by quality, not ads

Find top-rated ice cream shop businesses in New York. Every business is ranked by Quality Score — our quality metric based on responsiveness, data completeness, and verified reviews. Not who pays the most.

Sugar Hill Creamery

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(101 reviews)

Claim this business
il laboratorio del gelato

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(1261 reviews)

Claim this business
Lake Effect Ice Cream

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(1266 reviews)

Claim this business
King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream

Kenmore, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(819 reviews)

Claim this business
Custard Corner & Grill

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.4(512 reviews)

Claim this business
Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(1081 reviews)

Claim this business
Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream

East Aurora, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(530 reviews)

Claim this business
Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(212 reviews)

Claim this business
Hanna's Frosty Treats

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(320 reviews)

Claim this business
NYC CREPES-N-SHAKES

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(283 reviews)

Claim this business
Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Irondequoit, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(216 reviews)

Claim this business
Big Papa's Creamery

Lancaster, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(51 reviews)

Claim this business
The Creamery Hilton

Hilton, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(36 reviews)

Claim this business
Julia Jean's Ice Cream

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(76 reviews)

Claim this business
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

Brooklyn, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(1414 reviews)

Claim this business
Caffè Panna

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(1368 reviews)

Claim this business
Sundaes Best

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(387 reviews)

Claim this business
Lake Effect Ice Cream

Lockport, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(1460 reviews)

Claim this business
Pittsford Farms Dairy

Pittsford, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(2910 reviews)

Claim this business
Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop

Rush, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.4(451 reviews)

Claim this business
Pittsford Farms Dairy

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(262 reviews)

Claim this business
Hedonist Artisan Chocolates

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(257 reviews)

Claim this business
Village Ice Cream Shop

Spencerport, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(278 reviews)

Claim this business
Plank Road Ice Cream

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(706 reviews)

Claim this business
luv handlz

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(216 reviews)

Claim this business
Peter's Polar Parlor

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(625 reviews)

Claim this business
Big Dip Ice Cream

North Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(648 reviews)

Claim this business
Cold Stone Creamery

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.2(156 reviews)

Claim this business
Fayette's

Fayetteville, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(138 reviews)

Claim this business
Roll Roll Ice Cream

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.3(72 reviews)

Claim this business
Golden Waffles

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(114 reviews)

Claim this business
Ice Cream Shack

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 3.0(2 reviews)

Claim this business
Cookies & Cream On Elmwood

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.1(176 reviews)

Claim this business
The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.4(2319 reviews)

Claim this business
Kenny's Corner Ice Cream

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(117 reviews)

Claim this business
Antoinette's Sweets Inc.

Depew, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(848 reviews)

Claim this business
Downtown Syracuse, NY

Downtown, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(2 reviews)

Claim this business
Golden Hour Treats & Things

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(274 reviews)

Claim this business
Shady Shack Ice Cream and Grill

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(86 reviews)

Claim this business
Green Acres Ice Cream

Depew, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(771 reviews)

Claim this business
White Rabbit Dessert Experience

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.3(905 reviews)

Claim this business
Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Greece, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(200 reviews)

Claim this business
Venchi

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(3822 reviews)

Claim this business
Morgenstern's BANANAS

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.2(1936 reviews)

Claim this business
Venchi Chocolate and Gelato NOMAD

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(2349 reviews)

Claim this business
Anita La Mamma del Gelato

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(635 reviews)

Claim this business
Sugar Hill Creamery

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(912 reviews)

Claim this business
Mississippi Mudds

Tonawanda, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.3(2036 reviews)

Claim this business
Anderson's Frozen Custard

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(872 reviews)

Claim this business
Russell's Ice Cream

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(829 reviews)

Claim this business

Don't see your business?

Add your business to Bezal for free and start getting found by AI search engines.

Get Listed on Bezal

Related Categories in New York

Junk RemovalKitchen RemodelingSign ShopWedding PlannerFlooringGarage Door RepairDentistMassage Therapist