Best Ice Cream Shop in New York (2026)

76 businesses found · Ranked by quality, not ads

Find top-rated ice cream shop businesses in New York. Every business is ranked by Quality Score, our measure of responsiveness, data completeness, and reviews. Not who pays the most.

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(284 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(829 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(706 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(274 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(76 reviews)

Brooklyn, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(1414 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(625 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(1845 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(3564 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(872 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(1904 reviews)

Baldwinsville, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(33 reviews)

Irondequoit, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(216 reviews)

Camillus, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(138 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.3(905 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.1(176 reviews)

Downtown, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(2 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(105 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(114 reviews)

Depew, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(771 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(320 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(257 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(666 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(1261 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.2(1936 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(462 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(212 reviews)

Fairport, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(204 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(86 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(101 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(993 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(387 reviews)

Buffalo, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(1081 reviews)

Hilton, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(36 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(1665 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(2349 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(3156 reviews)

Spencerport, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(278 reviews)

Tonawanda, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.3(768 reviews)

Rochester, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(10 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(635 reviews)

Depew, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(848 reviews)

North Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(648 reviews)

Lancaster, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(51 reviews)

Webster, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(992 reviews)

Greece, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(200 reviews)

New York, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(1368 reviews)

Canandaigua, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(821 reviews)

Rush, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.4(451 reviews)

Syracuse, NY

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.2(156 reviews)

Don't see your business?

Add your business to Bezal for free and start getting found by AI search engines.

Get Listed on Bezal

Related Categories in New York