Bezal.
Find a ProviderSign In

Best Italian Restaurant in New York (2026)

66 businesses found · Ranked by quality, not ads

Find top-rated italian restaurant businesses in New York. Every business is ranked by Quality Score — our quality metric based on responsiveness, data completeness, and verified reviews. Not who pays the most.

Mulberry Italian Ristorante

Lackawanna, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(2549 reviews)

Claim this business
Angotti's | Family Restaurant

Syracuse, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(496 reviews)

Claim this business
Pane Vino On The River

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(1121 reviews)

Claim this business
La Pecora Bianca SoHo

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.8(5663 reviews)

Claim this business
Ilio DiPaolo's Restaurant & Banquet Facility

Blasdell, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(2759 reviews)

Claim this business
Osteria Barocca

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(2929 reviews)

Claim this business
La Masseria NY

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(1626 reviews)

Claim this business
Lucia's On The Lake

Hamburg, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(1580 reviews)

Claim this business
INIZIO

Buffalo, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(301 reviews)

Claim this business
The Pasta Villa

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(1571 reviews)

Claim this business
La Pecora Bianca Bryant Park

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.8(6857 reviews)

Claim this business
Osteria La Baia

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.9(5279 reviews)

Claim this business
OLIO E PIÙ

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(10708 reviews)

Claim this business
Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(2492 reviews)

Claim this business
Sicily Osteria

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(3100 reviews)

Claim this business
da Toscano

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(590 reviews)

Claim this business
Trattoria Trecolori

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(2883 reviews)

Claim this business
Fiamma Centro

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.1(891 reviews)

Claim this business
Masseria Dei Vini

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(987 reviews)

Claim this business
Branca Midtown

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(681 reviews)

Claim this business
Italian Prime at Salvatore's

Depew, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.2(2234 reviews)

Claim this business
JT’s Urban Italian

Buffalo, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(900 reviews)

Claim this business
The Italian Village

Depew, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(1364 reviews)

Claim this business
Tony D's

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(1425 reviews)

Claim this business
Lucano

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(396 reviews)

Claim this business
Polizzi's

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(393 reviews)

Claim this business
Joey's Italian Restaurant

Syracuse, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(1958 reviews)

Claim this business
Mr. Dominic's at the Lake

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(1217 reviews)

Claim this business
Perlo's Restaurant

East Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(1069 reviews)

Claim this business
Rocky's

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(803 reviews)

Claim this business
Giuseppe's

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(1115 reviews)

Claim this business
Grotto

North Syracuse, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(630 reviews)

Claim this business
Attilio's

Syracuse, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(423 reviews)

Claim this business
Carrabba's Italian Grill

Fayetteville, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(2248 reviews)

Claim this business
Strada Mia 313

Syracuse, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.2(701 reviews)

Claim this business
Rosalie's Cucina

Skaneateles, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(783 reviews)

Claim this business
Avicolli's Coal Fire

Fayetteville, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(727 reviews)

Claim this business
Vito's Ristorante

East Syracuse, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(970 reviews)

Claim this business
Tony's Di Napoli

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(8129 reviews)

Claim this business
Piccola Cucina Uptown

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(2317 reviews)

Claim this business
La Pecora Bianca NoMad

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(5830 reviews)

Claim this business
Da Andrea Greenwich Village

New York, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(2560 reviews)

Claim this business
Lombardo

Buffalo, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(775 reviews)

Claim this business
Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse

Rochester, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.4(2898 reviews)

Claim this business
Giancarlo’s Sicilian Steakhouse

Williamsville, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.6(1484 reviews)

Claim this business
Giacobbi's Cucina Citta

Buffalo, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(446 reviews)

Claim this business
La Bella Sicilia

Buffalo, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(2479 reviews)

Claim this business
Daniela

Buffalo, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.8(530 reviews)

Claim this business
San Marco

Buffalo, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.7(420 reviews)

Claim this business
Sinatra's

Kenmore, NY

Italian Restaurant

★ 4.5(683 reviews)

Claim this business

Don't see your business?

Add your business to Bezal for free and start getting found by AI search engines.

Get Listed on Bezal

Related Categories in New York

TutorTailorBody ShopPersonal TrainerSteakhouseCoffee ShopFood TruckTransmission Repair