Bezal.
Find a ProviderSign In

Best Ice Cream Shop in New Jersey (2026)

59 businesses found · Ranked by quality, not ads

Find top-rated ice cream shop businesses in New Jersey. Every business is ranked by Quality Score — our quality metric based on responsiveness, data completeness, and verified reviews. Not who pays the most.

Gelato Fruity & Coffee

Newark, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(24 reviews)

Claim this business
Salaam Ice Cream Parlor

Newark, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(145 reviews)

Claim this business
Magic Cones Plant Based Ice Cream Parlor

Newark, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(13 reviews)

Claim this business
Honey & Hive Artisanal Ice Cream

Maplewood, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(226 reviews)

Claim this business
Maybel's Ice Cream Bar

Newark, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 2.5(2 reviews)

Claim this business
Harvy's

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(1049 reviews)

Claim this business
MilkShake Factory Downtown Jersey City

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(60 reviews)

Claim this business
Torico Ice Cream

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(2244 reviews)

Claim this business
M2ICE

Newark, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(122 reviews)

Claim this business
Applegate Farm

Montclair, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(3280 reviews)

Claim this business
The Shake N Bite

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(8 reviews)

Claim this business
Ice Moon

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(319 reviews)

Claim this business
16 Handles

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 3.8(77 reviews)

Claim this business
Thomas' Ice Cream - Jersey City

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(8 reviews)

Claim this business
Dr.Fruit

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(615 reviews)

Claim this business
Uncle Louie G Italian ice and Ice Cream

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(97 reviews)

Claim this business
Holsten's Ice Cream, Chocolate & Restaurant

Bloomfield, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(2048 reviews)

Claim this business
Stack Creamery

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(606 reviews)

Claim this business
Crumbly Cookies Co.

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.4(202 reviews)

Claim this business
Gelato Italiano

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.0(21 reviews)

Claim this business
Magic Fountain

Bayonne, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(520 reviews)

Claim this business
ZRolls Ice Cream

Harrison, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(717 reviews)

Claim this business
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(293 reviews)

Claim this business
Torico Ice Cream

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(45 reviews)

Claim this business
Cold Stone

Newark, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.0(75 reviews)

Claim this business
Jersey & Co. Gelato

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(221 reviews)

Claim this business
Morelia Ice Cream Paletas - Hoboken

Hoboken, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(939 reviews)

Claim this business
Jabal Creamery

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.9(410 reviews)

Claim this business
Mango Mango Dessert - Jersey City

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(377 reviews)

Claim this business
MR WAFFLES Paterson

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(329 reviews)

Claim this business
Bora Bora Smoothie Cafe - Paterson New Jersey

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(114 reviews)

Claim this business
Angel's Recipe Ice Cream & Crepes

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.5(660 reviews)

Claim this business
Cold Stone Creamery

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 3.5(81 reviews)

Claim this business
Silver Fox ice cream shop

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(3 reviews)

Claim this business
Four Seasons Ice Cream

Elmwood Park, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(307 reviews)

Claim this business
Bolgati Helados con Queso

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 3.7(50 reviews)

Claim this business
Gia Gelato & Cafe

Jersey City, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.3(204 reviews)

Claim this business
New Territories Ice Cream

Fair Lawn, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(166 reviews)

Claim this business
Hometown Creamery

Wayne, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(263 reviews)

Claim this business
Everest LLC

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.1(45 reviews)

Claim this business
Guernsey Crest Ice Cream Co

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.7(1202 reviews)

Claim this business
Dingman's Dairy

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(29 reviews)

Claim this business
Gelotti Ice Cream

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(2052 reviews)

Claim this business
Wards Ice Cream Co Inc

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(69 reviews)

Claim this business
Goffle Creamery

Hawthorne, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(210 reviews)

Claim this business
Helados Paterso

Paterson, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.6(44 reviews)

Claim this business
Cold Stone Creamery

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.0(92 reviews)

Claim this business
Mehadrin Ice Cream

Elizabethport, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 5.0(1 review)

Claim this business
t-swirl

Elizabeth, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.2(18 reviews)

Claim this business
Wholly Cow

Rahway, NJ

Ice Cream Shop

★ 4.8(157 reviews)

Claim this business

Don't see your business?

Add your business to Bezal for free and start getting found by AI search engines.

Get Listed on Bezal

Related Categories in New Jersey

Physical TherapistMartial ArtsDance StudioGarage Door RepairHouse PaintingDentistPersonal TrainerManagement Consulting